Start with the guitar that is used in the music you want to play. That’s the answer I give beginners as one of the moderators on the Reddit r/guitar subreddit when they ask, “Should I start leaning with an acoustic or an electric guitar?”.
Pick a Guitar that Matches Your Music
Guitars that match your music is a key factor in maintaining your motivation to continue learning. Motivation will keep you going through the not so fun times when things aren’t going as well as you’d like. Learning the songs that you love with the guitar used in those songs is one of the best ways to maintain motivation. It is as simple as that. The skills learned on electric or acoustic guitar are highly transferable. You can easily take what you’ve learned on one and use it with the other. Basic technique really isn’t the deciding factor in choosing between the two, so choose the guitar used in the songs that you love.
Choosing a Guitar for a Child
If your child is one of those kids who clearly knows what they want to play, your choices are easier. Here are some things to consider if you’re a parent and choosing a guitar for a child whose music tastes aren’t so clear.
- Cost
- Motivation & Persistence
- Size
Why Start with Acoustic Guitar?
- Simplicity and Accessibility: Acoustic guitars don’t require amplifiers or extra equipment, making them a cost-effective and straightforward option for beginners.
- Skill Development: The thicker strings and higher action of acoustic guitars build finger strength and dexterity more quickly. Mastering these challenges can make transitioning to an electric guitar easier.
- Versatility: Acoustic guitars are great for learning the basics of music theory, chords, and strumming patterns. They suit a wide variety of genres, from folk to pop.
- Portability: Acoustics are easier to carry and play anywhere, fostering consistent practice habits.
Why Start with Electric Guitar?
- Playability: Electric guitars generally have lighter strings and lower action, making them easier on the fingers for beginners.
- Motivation: Electric guitars can feel more “fun” for some due to their dynamic sound and iconic status in music history.
Conclusion
Ultimately, there’s no “wrong” choice. Both types of guitars teach the fundamental skills that you can transfer to other style guitar if and when you decide to.